• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Login
  • Register
Publishers Lunch logo Publishers Lunch logo
  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help
Login Sign Up
  • Personnel
  • AI
  • Compensation
  • Unions
  • Book Bans
  • New Releases
  • Earnings
  • The Trial
  • Archives
Publishers Lunch logo
  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help
  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help

March 8, 2012By Michael Cader

Justice Department Said to Threaten Suit Over Agency eBook Pricing

March 8, 2012By Michael Cader

The Wall Street Journal says that the Justice Department’s lengthy investigation of the agency model for ebook pricing has escalated, with the government threatening to sue the “Agency Five” publishers and Apple “for allegedly colluding to raise the price of electronic books, according to people familiar with the matter.” The paper says that “some but not all” of the publishers involved have held settlement talks with Justice. Those same people said “the Justice Department believes that Apple and the publishers acted in concert to raise prices across the industry, and is prepared to sue them for violating federal antitrust laws.”

One publishing executive says the discussions have been underway for a long time and “negotiations have taken many turns.” Another executive said “a settlement is being considered for pragmatic reasons but by no means are we close.” That person added, “You have to consider a settlement, whether you think it’s fair or not.” Under the Sherman Act, corporations face a maximum fine of $100 million for violations. A Justice Department “antitrust primer” notes that “in addition, collusion among competitors may constitute violations of the mail or wire fraud statute, the false statements statute, or other federal felony statutes.”

Among the possible solutions, “one idea floated by publishers to settle the case is to preserve the agency model but allow some discounts by booksellers, according to the people familiar with the matter.” The paper notes that BN ceo William Lynch is said to have testified to Justice that the agency model promoted a marketplace that provides consumers with choices, arguing that without it a single player–the one that can afford to lose money, using what some argue is predatory pricing–would have an even more dominant market share.

In an “antitrust primer,” Justice maintains that proving illegal price-fixing “does not require us to show that the conspirators entered into a formal written or express agreement. Price fixing, bid rigging, and other collusive agreements can be established either by direct evidence, such as the testimony of a participant, or by circumstantial evidence, such as suspicious bid patterns, travel and expense reports, telephone records, and business diary entries.”

There has been tension in the interpretation of the Sherman Act ever since the Supreme Court’s 2007 ruling in the Leegin Creative Leather Products case. The Court reversed almost 100 years of judicial precedent that found vertical price restraints were illegal per se, and substituted a “rule of reason” and recognized retail price maintenance can in some cases have a “procompetitive effect that are in the  consumer’s best interest.”

Meanwhile, Google Play’s new promotion offering a different ebook every day for 25 cents is doing wonders for Amazon. Jonathan Safran Foer’s Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close rose to No. 1 on the hourly Kindle bestseller list when Amazon matched the 25-cent price and is still there, at least for now, at the revised price of $7.03. Gaining on it is Chuck Palahniuk’s FIGHT CLUB, the next Google promotion, now at No. 8 on Amazon’s list (after ranking in the 40,000s last night).

Filed Under: Agency, DOJ, eNews, Free, Legal

sidebar

Primary Free Sidebar

Login

Forgot Password Quick Pass User Login
Get Full Access
The Publishing Industry’s Essential Daily Read

Each Publishers Lunch Deluxe subscription includes full access to our searchable multi-year archive of industry news, a nightly email reporting 10 to 50 deal transactions, and our database of industry contacts, scripts, and posting privileges.

Learn More

RSS feed: Automat Automat

  • AI-Generated Publishing News Site Falsely Reports That Sylvie Rabineau Left WME, Porter Anderson is Alive, and More Invented Slop November 16, 2026 Publishing Post
  • National Book Award Nonfiction Nominee Abdelrahman ElGendy Was Denied Visa to Attend Ceremony November 13, 2026 New Yorker
  • Caine Writing Prize Stands by Winner Simbarashe Kundizeza After Investigation: "We feel the evidence is clear" November 12, 2026 AP
  • A "Flourishing of Niche Bookstores" November 12, 2026 Bloomberg
  • Foundation Books Unveils First Titles in Macmillan Partnership November 11, 2026 Hollywood Reporter
  • Scholastic Catalogue Now Available on Spotify Premium November 11, 2026 Spotify Newsroom
  • Michel Houellebecq Indicted In France For Comments About Muslims November 11, 2026 Le Monde
  • Maryland Governor Wes Moore's REPAIR: Healing a Divided Nation to Publish March 9 From Holt November 11, 2026 AP
  • Reagan Arthur at Cardinal Said to Buy New Monica Lewinsky Memoir, Sold by Suzanne Gluck and Alyssa Reuben at WME November 10, 2026 Page Six
  • Pete Buttigieg's NEXT Forthcoming From Simon Six in January November 10, 2026 Simon & Schuster
Publishers Marketplace logo

Contact Us

News

  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Report News
  • Discuss
  • Classifieds
  • Rights Offerings

Deals

  • Report A Deal

Books

  • Buzz Books

Jobs

  • Job Board
  • Privacy Policy Terms of Use