• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Login
  • Register

Publishers Lunch

The Publishing Industry's Daily Essential Read

  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help

Barnes & Noble: Talks Collapse, Company Wins In Delaware, Burkle Launches Proxy Fight

August 13, 2010
By Michael Cader

As Friday the 13th today would have provided more appropriate timing for the latest events in Barnes & Noble’s corporate soap opera. Though the press release was reportedly ready to go announcing the settlement between the company and activist shareholder Ron Burkle, and Delaware vice chancellor Leo Strine had been notified a settlement was close (NYT), during a conference call yesterday morning “to review final details…negotiations broke down” (WSJ).

By 12:30 Barnes & Noble announced they “were unable to conclude an agreement on mutually acceptable terms”; hours later, Strine issued his ruling, not unsurprisingly supporting the company. He concluded that the poison pill “rights plan was a proportional response to the threat the company faced” and was reasonably designed to prevent “a creeping acquisition without the benefit of receiving a control premium.”

As threatened, by the close of business Burkle’s Yucaipa filed paperwork with the SEC launching a proxy fight designed to unseat chairman Len Riggio and two other current BN board members at the annual meeting on September 28, and asking shareholders to amend the poison pill to allow so that Burkle (and others) could accumulate up to 30 percent of shares before the defense mechanism is triggered. Yucaipa is running Burkle, Wheego car ceo Michael McQuary, and Stephen Bollenbach (advertised during the settlement negotiations as an “independent” director, even though he has clear ties to Burkle) for the board of directors.

As Strine pointed out in his ruling, “there is good reason to believe that Yucaipa will succeed in a proxy contest” with the support of “admiring and devoted fellow traveler” Aletheia plus the votes of other institutional owners. Strine reckoned that if about 91 percent of shares are voted–with about 38 percent locked up by the Riggios and insiders, and an almost equal amount with Burkle and Aletheia–shareholders controlling 8 percent of the stock, or approximately 4.75 million shares, could tip the balance. (According to online records, the four largest institutional owners hold over 7 million shares by themselves.)

The market has been understandably perplexed by the developments: yesterday shares were up on the rumor settled, down on the end of talks, up again with the Delaware verdict, and down again this morning on the looming proxy fight.

The big question now is whether this proxy fight ever makes it as far as the annual meeting. While some investment analysts have questioned whether founder and chairman Len Riggio wants to take the company private or is ready to cash out and let someone else take control, the idea of Barnes & Noble as a public company without Riggio on the board–exercising a strong voice on the company’s “strategic alternatives”–is all but inconceivable. As chancellor Strine observed in his ruling, though BN technically and barely meets the criteria for having a majority of independent directors, it “continues to have a good deal of the feel of the board of a controlled company.”

So our reasoning would suggest that if Barnes & Noble cannot guarantee sufficient support for its slate of directors in a very short timeframe, the odds of a deal to take the company private only increase.

Filed Under: Bookstores, Finance, Free

sidebar

Primary Free Sidebar

Login


Forgot password
Quick Pass users click here to log in
Get Full Access
The publishing industry's essential daily read

Each Publishers Lunch Deluxe subscription includes full access to our searchable multi-year archive of industry news, a nightly email reporting 10 to 50 deal transactions, and our database of industry contacts, scripts, and posting privileges.

Learn More

RSS Automat

  • Jefferson, de Kretser Win Folio Prizes March 27, 2023 Prize announcement
  • Harper UK Edits Agatha Christie Novels to Remove "Offensive" Language March 27, 2023 The Guardian
  • NYU Launches Five-Day "Advanced Publishing Institute" Program for January 2024 March 25, 2023 NYU site
  • Hachette UK to Publish "Spare Us!" Parody on April 6 March 23, 2023 Publisher site
  • Netflix to Stream Series Based on Ramit Sethi's Book, "How to Get Rich" March 23, 2023 THR
  • James Patterson Signs First-Look Development Deal with Skydance Television March 22, 2023 Deadline
  • "I find it kind of stunning that the [Internet] Archive would put its entire free service at risk over such an obviously wrong stand" March 21, 2023 Dan Kennedy / Media Nation
  • Douglas Stuart's Young Mungo Is Being Adapated Into a TV Series by A24 March 21, 2023 Deadline
  • Reid Hoffman Posts a Free eBook About His Experiences with ChaptGPT-4 March 16, 2023 Free PDF
  • Siri Hustvedt Reveals that Paul Auster Is Receiving Cancer Treatment at Sloan Kettering March 14, 2023 Instagram post
© 2023 Publishers Lunch. All Rights Reserved.