• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Login
  • Register

Publishers Lunch

The Publishing Industry's Daily Essential Read

  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help

Posner and Simon & Schuster Sued for Infringement, As Publisher Faces Odd Campaign Finance Allegations As Well

September 8, 2010
By Michael Cader

In March Gerald Posner admitted his fall 2009 book MIAMI BABYLON included some passages from Frank Owen’s CLUBLAND. At the time, Posner blamed faulty research methodology, and said “if you use something from another book, a statement from another book, it needs to be in quotations, or if you take something and put it in your own syntax and grammar, you still need to cite it.” He promised to review his book further and revise the material. (This came a month after Posner resigned from the Daily Beast after it was found that he copied material from  Miami Herald articles online, which he said was “inadvertent.”)

Now Owen has filed suit in a Manhattan Federal court against Posner and publishers Simon & Schuster, alleging “numerous examples of word-for-word copying.” Claiming copyright infringement, the suit says Posner’s book “is little more than a frequently verbatim precis of significant portions of Clubland, a verbal reduction sauce in which 30,000 words are reduced down to approximately 10,000 and yet the flavor remains the same.” In a separately posted letter, Owen writes that “Simon & Schuster has known since March that Miami Babylon contains dozens of plagiarized passages, yet six months later, they continue to sell the book. It’s obvious that Simon and Schuster not only condones plagiarism but continues to profit from it.”

The suit cites many comparative passages, though most are one to three sentences long. But they allege broadly that “through approximately 10,000 words of Miami Babylon, Posner almost exactly copied Mr. Owen’s sequencing of events (even when not purely chronological); Mr. Owen’s use of third party sources; Mr. Owen’s factual sequencing; Mr. Owen’s use of quotations and the emphasis provided by such quotations. In short, Posner’s theft of Mr. Owen’s protected expression was not only by verbatim copying.”

Simon & Schuster spokesman Adam Rothberg tells the NY Post that while Posner acknowledges “inadvertently used phrases” that “to suggest that this usage amounts to copyright infringement is entirely without merit. As the complaint makes clear the unattributed use of phrases at issue was limited and in the reporting of factual events. Mr. Posner and Simon & Schuster will vigorously defend this lawsuit.”
NY Post
Filing

In a more unusual allegation, last week an attorney for the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee wrote to Simon & Schuster, “hinting that the publisher may have violated several campaign finance laws that prohibit in-kind contributions by corporations by posting on its website a promotional video” for the book YOUNG GUNS: A New Generation of Conservative Leaders. Politico reported that because the video is produced by Representative Eric Cantor’s PAC, the publisher’s posting “seems to use corporate resources in coordination with Congressman Cantor to redistribute his leadership PAC’s partisan campaign material.”

S&S did not respond to Politico’s story.
Politico

Filed Under: Free, Legal

sidebar

Primary Free Sidebar

Login


Forgot password
Quick Pass users click here to log in
Get Full Access
The publishing industry's essential daily read

Each Publishers Lunch Deluxe subscription includes full access to our searchable multi-year archive of industry news, a nightly email reporting 10 to 50 deal transactions, and our database of industry contacts, scripts, and posting privileges.

Learn More

RSS Automat

  • UK Publisher Peter Usborne, 85, Died "Unexpectedly but Peacefully" March 30, 2023 Bookseller
  • Dublin Literary Award Shortlist Announced March 30, 2023 Prize site
  • Leigh Bardugo Signs with WME for Film/TV Representation March 29, 2023 Variety
  • Solid State Books Workers Announce Plans to Unionize March 28, 2023 Union website
  • Following Sale, America's Test Kitchen Lays Off 23 Employees, Including All of ATK Kids Staff March 28, 2023 Union instagram post
  • Acquire and Fire: Hachette UK In Consultations to Eliminate About Half the Staff of Welbeck March 28, 2023 Bookseller
  • Jefferson, de Kretser Win Folio Prizes March 27, 2023 Prize announcement
  • Harper UK Edits Agatha Christie Novels to Remove "Offensive" Language March 27, 2023 The Guardian
  • NYU Launches Five-Day "Advanced Publishing Institute" Program for January 2024 March 25, 2023 NYU site
  • Hachette UK to Publish "Spare Us!" Parody on April 6 March 23, 2023 Publisher site
© 2023 Publishers Lunch. All Rights Reserved.