• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Login
  • Register

Publishers Lunch

The Publishing Industry's Daily Essential Read

  • Publishers Marketplace
  • Site Guide
  • Help

Chin Approves Schedule for Discovery and Motions Moving to Google Books Trial

September 15, 2011
By Michael Cader

At today’s court hearing to update Judge Denny Chin, the parties to the Google Books case brought no dramatic reports of progress on a settlement (as widely expected), despite the judge’s warning the last time around to work out a deal or prepare to litigate. So Judge Chin followed through on his promise and scheduled a pathway to trial, albeit a slow one.

Attorney Michael Boni, speaking for the Authors Guild only this time, said the authors organization remains in “active discussions” with Google about a settlement as part of a “parallel track” of preparing for litigation. Representatives of the AAP thought they had “made enough progress with Google” to believe a new settlement could still be a possibility, but they agreed to adopt the proposed order moving to litigation. In a brief statement afterwards, the AAP said “today, we informed the court that the Association of American Publishers, the five publisher plaintiffs and Google have made good progress toward a settlement that would resolve the pending litigation regarding the Google Library Project. We are working to resolve the differences that remain between the parties and reach terms that are mutually agreeable.

The judge called for discovery to begin now and run through March 30. By our reporter Sarah Weinman’s count, the weary Judge Chin held his head in his hands three times during the relatively short hearing. The process has already taken so long that the original magistrate who might have helped with the settlement has retired. (And Chin is supposed to have a full caseload on the Court of Appeals; he doesn’t even know where a trial would be held, since he is losing his courtroom). But Judge Chin once again actively encouraged both parties to seek him and the court out to help arrive at a settlement agreement.

Even swift litigation runs slowly; here is the “generous but acceptable” calendar the judge agreed to, which still would mean no actual trial likely until next fall or beyond, which will be recapped in his official order, filed later today:

Opening briefs from the plaintiffs by December 12, a response from Google by January 26, a rebuttal by March 12, expert reports by April 20, rebuttal by May 10, expert depositions from May 14–25, a summary judgment motion due by May 31, opposition filings by July 9, replies by July 31.

Filed Under: eNews, Free, Legal

sidebar

Primary Free Sidebar

Login


Forgot password
Quick Pass users click here to log in
Get Full Access
The publishing industry's essential daily read

Each Publishers Lunch Deluxe subscription includes full access to our searchable multi-year archive of industry news, a nightly email reporting 10 to 50 deal transactions, and our database of industry contacts, scripts, and posting privileges.

Learn More

RSS Automat

  • Jordan Peterson Suspended on Twitter for "Hateful Conduct" In Comment About Elliot Page July 1, 2022 NY Post
  • Rushdie Will Move From Random House to Knopf for Next Novel, in 2023 (Update: The Bookseller Reported This Incorrectly) June 30, 2022 Bookseller
  • Macmillan Cyber Attack Gets National Coverage; Retailers Don't Mind, But It Still Hurts Authors and the Company June 30, 2022 WSJ
  • Wattpad Is Buying Exclusivity to Some of their Most Popular Authors and Stories with Stipends of Up to $25,000 June 30, 2022 Press Release
  • Supreme Court Declines to Review or Revise Landmark NYT v. Sullivan Libel Standard, Despite Clarence Thomas's Objection June 27, 2022 CNN
  • So Far, Books by Trump Aides Are Mostly...Losers June 23, 2022 Politico
  • Macmillan Nigeria Publisher Charged With Book Fraud June 21, 2022 The Herald
  • All The Exiting Agents Seem to Think ICM's Sale to CAA Will Get Approved Shortly by DOJ June 17, 2022 Deadline
  • Spotify Closes Findaway Acquisition: "Their technology will help propel Spotify into the rapidly growing audiobooks industry" June 17, 2022 Press Release
  • Australian Author John Hughes "Unintentionally" Plagiarized The Great Gatsby And Other Famous Works In His New Novel June 15, 2022 The Guardian
© 2022 Publishers Lunch. All Rights Reserved.