US District Judge Denise Cote formally denied motions by the five agency publishers and Apple to dismiss the class action suit on behalf of ebook consumers over the alleged conspiracy to raise ebook prices via the agency model. The ruling was not unexpected, given the relatively low standards of “stat[ing] a plausible claim” for such a suit to go forward: “Proving conspiracy requires demonstrating ‘a unity of purpose or a common design and understanding, or a meeting of minds in an unlawful arrangement.’ The [complaint] plausibly alleges that each of the defendants shared the twin purposes of raising the price […]
Legal
Responses to the Georgia State University Fair Use Ruling
A number of plaintiffs and interested parties have responded Monday to last week’s ruling in the Georgia State University e-reserves lawsuit that found 5 instances of infringement but otherwise dismissed more than 64 instances, and AAP president Tom Allen and the organization’s lead attorney in the case Bruce Rich convened a press briefing by phone on Tuesday morning. Allen that the AAP alone has invested “several million dollars” in the case so far. He underscored that “our members are very conscious that the universities and their libraries are our customers.” Allen added, “our hope is that this is an important […]
Legal Briefs: 17 More States Join Amended eBook Pricing Complaint; ‘Godfather’ Sequel Proceeds in Escrow; and More
Late last week 16 more states, as well as the District of Columbia, joined the amended ebook pricing complaint against Apple and the ‘Agency Five’ publishers, bringing the number of states involved in the lawsuit to 32. Texas and Connecticut initially filed the complaint at the same time as the DOJ; among the new plaintiffs are Virginia, Indiana, New York, and Wisconsin. Page One Bookstore in Albuquerque, NM, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in February 2011, said it expects final approval of a reorganization plan to move forward as a going concern “shortly,” according to the Albuquerque Journal. Owner […]
Judge Finds 5 Cases of Infringement In Georgia State Fair Use Case, But Dismisses All Other Counts
Judge Orinda Evans of the Northern District of Georgia published her 350-page ruling late Friday on the closely-watched copyright infringement case originally brought in 2008 against Georgia State University by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, and SAGE Publications. (Actual costs were shared by the Copyright Clearance Center and the AAP, leading the judge to “infer that CCC and AAP organized the litigation and recruited the three plaintiffs to participate.” The ruling–finding the university did infringe in five cases (out of 75 claimed infringements)–has enough room in it to allow most interested parties to claim victory, dissatisfaction, or both, depending […]
Dear DOJ: Agents Speak Out
The 13-member board of the Association of Authors Representatives has sent a letter to the Department of Justice opposing the proposed agency ebook pricing settlement with Hachette Book Group, HarperCollins, and Simon & Schuster. In a separate email, the AAR called on members “to express their views on the settlement to the DOJ and we hope you will also urge your clients to do the same. Your note might address whether you feel the settlement will foster competition and well-being in the literary marketplace, or the opposite…. We believe it is tremendously important that we all be heard on this […]
Guild and Google Are Back Before Judge Chin, Arguing Over Class Status
Going on seven years later, Google and the Authors Guild are still squabbling over the basic of their lawsuit before Judge Denny Chin (who has otherwise moved on in his career, sitting on the Second Circuit Court of Appeals). Google is challenging the Guild’s new request for certification of the class, spurred by questions about the whether the proposed class could adequately represent the vast interests of different authors during arguments over the rejected settlement of the suit. Google attorney Daralyn Durie confirmed that they continue to negotiate with publishers and photographers, though a representative for the latter said “I […]